A discussion of Beyerskloof Wine Bar (Pty) Ltd v Williams (Case No. 16561/20; A02/2026)
1. Introduction
Can a restaurant automatically be held responsible when a customer finds a dangerous foreign object in their food? Does the fact that someone gets injured after eating food served by a restaurant mean that the restaurant was negligent?
These were some of the important questions considered by the full bench of the Western Cape Division of the High Court in Beyerskloof Wine Bar (Pty) Ltd v Williams, decided on 12 October 2026.
The case involved a woman who swallowed a needle-like object while eating a hamburger at the restaurant. Although the trial court found the restaurant liable for her injuries, the full bench overturned that decision on appeal.
The judgment is important because it explains that, although businesses must take reasonable steps to protect their customers, they are not automatically legally responsible whenever an unfortunate incident occurs. A person claiming compensation must still prove that the business was legally at fault.
2. Background of the case
On 3 October 2020, Maxine Williams visited Beyerskloof Wine Bar with her husband.
They ordered food and drinks, including hamburgers.
While eating her hamburger, Williams suddenly experienced discomfort in her throat.
She felt as though something was stuck and began coughing. After going to the bathroom, she noticed blood and became frightened. She informed her husband that she was unable to dislodge the object from her throat and became overwhelmed with stress and anxiety. They immediately went to Stellenbosch Mediclinic for medical assistance.
X-rays revealed that a needle-like foreign object was stuck in her throat. Doctors attempted to remove it but were initially unsuccessful. The ENT specialist attempted to remove or extract the object manually but could not succeed. She underwent an operation after 7 hours which was unsuccessful. To monitor the location of the foreign object, she was hospitalised and x-rays were performed twice daily and additionally, she was administered medication to facilitate its elimination from her body. She was hospitalised for 5 days and was discharged on the 5th day when the foreign object was no longer visible on the x-rays. Williams believed that the object must have come from the hamburger served by the restaurant. She denied that it could have come from her clothing or her husband’s clothing.
However, she could not explain exactly where the object had been in the hamburger.
She was also unable to establish how it had entered the food. She subsequently sued the restaurant, arguing that it had failed to ensure that the food served to customers was safe for consumption.
The trial court agreed with her and found the restaurant liable. The restaurant, however, disagreed with this decision and appealed.
3. What did the appeal court have to decide?
The appeal court had to decide whether the restaurant should legally be held responsible for Williams’s injuries.
The court had to consider three main questions:
- Was the restaurant negligent?
- Could the court assume that the restaurant was negligent simply because a foreign object was found in the food?
- Could the restaurant be held responsible automatically, without proof of negligence?
To answer these questions, the court considered some important principles of South African law.
4. The court’s reasoning
4.1 The principle of res ipsa loquitur
One of the main legal principles in this case was res ipsa loquitur, a Latin expression meaning “the thing speaks for itself”.
This principle allows a court, in appropriate circumstances, to infer that someone may have been negligent based on the way an incident happened, even when there is no direct evidence explaining exactly what went wrong.
For example, if a properly maintained object falls from a building and injures someone, the surrounding circumstances might justify an inference that someone failed to take reasonable care.
Williams argued that the same reasoning should apply because a needle-like object was found in the food prepared and served by the restaurant. The initial court accepted this argument and expected the restaurant to explain how the object had entered the hamburger.
However, the appeal court disagreed with how the principle had been applied. It explained that res ipsa loquitur does not automatically prove negligence and does not transfer the legal responsibility of proving a case from the person bringing the claim to the defendant.
In other words, the fact that something went wrong does not automatically mean that the restaurant was careless.
The court must consider all the available evidence before deciding whether negligence has been established.
4.2 Was the restaurant negligent?
The court also considered whether the restaurant had failed to take reasonable steps to protect its customers.
South African law uses the reasonable person test to determine negligence. This asks whether an ordinary reasonable person in the same circumstances would have anticipated the possibility of harm and taken reasonable steps to prevent it.
The restaurant’s manager testified that the business has health and safety procedures in place. Employees were trained, food deliveries were checked and plastic brushes were used to clean the grills instead of metal brushes.
He also explained that the restaurant had never experienced an incident of this nature before.
An important difficulty for Williams was that she could not identify which part of the hamburger contained the foreign object or explain how it had entered the food.
The appeal court therefore found that there was insufficient evidence to establish that the restaurant could reasonably have anticipated this particular risk in the circumstances.
The court also considered whether the restaurant should have taken additional precautions, such as scanning every ingredient or meal with a metal detector or examining every ingredient using X-rays.
It found that such measures would be unreasonable and excessive.
The court emphasised that the law does not expect businesses to take every possible precaution, but rather to take reasonable precautions against foreseeable risks.
Consequently, the court found that Williams had not proved that the restaurant was negligent.
4.3 Can a restaurant automatically be held liable?
The court also considered whether the restaurant could be held responsible simply because the food served to Williams contained a foreign object.
This relates to the concept of strict liability.
Strict liability means that someone can be held legally responsible for harm without the injured person having to prove ordinary negligence. The court referred to the Supreme Court of Appeal decision in Wagener v Pharmacare Ltd; Cuttings v Pharmacare Ltd ([2003] ZASCA 30; 2003 (4) SA 285 (SCA).
That case confirmed that South African common law does not generally impose strict liability in product liability cases. The court explained that a person seeking compensation must still rely on the ordinary legal principles governing delictual claims, unless legislation provides otherwise.
Therefore, the restaurant could not automatically be held liable merely because a foreign object was found in the food. Williams still had to prove the legal requirements for a delictual claim.
5. What was the final decision?
The full bench upheld the restaurant’s appeal.
It set aside the original court order and replaced it with an order dismissing Williams’s claim.
This meant that the restaurant was no longer legally liable to compensate her for the damages claimed.
The court also ordered Williams to pay the restaurant’s legal costs, including the costs of the trial and appeal proceedings.
6. Why is this judgment important?
This judgment is important because it reminds us that suffering an injury does not automatically mean that another person or business is legally responsible.
For customers, it shows that a person claiming compensation must provide sufficient evidence to establish that the business was legally at fault.
7. Conclusion
In Beyerskloof Wine Bar (Pty) Ltd v Williams, the court had to balance an unfortunate injury suffered by a customer against the legal requirements for holding a business responsible.
Written by Mr Sifiso Vincent Makhoba, Candidate Legal Practitioner, Pretoria, and reviewed by Ms M Maganbhai-Mooloo, Head of Litigation, Pretoria.
Sources
Beyerskloof Wine Bar (Pty) Ltd v Williams, Case No. (16561/20; A02/2026) [2026] ZAWCHC 593 (12 October 2026)