CONTACT US TODAY FOR CONSULTATION : 0861 674 352

CONTACT US TODAY FOR CONSULTATION : 0861 674 352

Temporary Incapacity in the Workplace

Introduction

The recent labour court judgement which was delivered in the case of Kongo v Commission for Mediation and Arbitration and Others, provides useful insight into the challenges that may arise when an employee is temporarily incapacitated by ill-health. The judgement highlights the need to find a balance between employee protection mechanisms within the workplace and the employer’s operational interests of the workplace.

Ms. Kongo was employed by the South African Rugby Union (herein now referred to as “SARU”) from December 2009 until her dismissal which took effect on the 1 December 2022. She developed depression and anxiety which she alleged was due to work stressors, including her tumultuous relationship with her manager, and her pending disciplinary proceedings. During the investigations into her incapacity, she proposed alternatives to her dismissal, including her working remotely, her receiving lighter duties and assistance from an independent life coach. She also further requested that the disciplinary hearing and investigations be postponed until her medical reassessment, which was to take place in the following year; however, the SARU proceeded with their investigation into her incapacity, which inevitably led to the termination of her employment contract on the basis of ill-health incapacity. Ms. Kongo then referred the matter to the Commission of Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (herein now referred to as the “CCMA”), where the arbitrator found the dismissal, was both substantively and procedurally fair. She then subsequently approached the Labour Court in terms of Section 145 of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 (herein now referred to as the ‘LRA’), to review the arbitration award. With the main issue before the court being whether arbitrator’s decision was one that a “reasonable” decisionmaker could reach.

The legal framework governing incapacity dismissals

An important consideration to make when dealing with incapacitated employees is the reciprocal nature of the employment relationship. The employee is required to render services, in line with their employment contract, while the employer is required to remunerate, provide a safe working environment and treat employees with basic dignity and fairness.

South African labour law recognises the employee’s rights to dignity, equality and fair labour practices. In the work environment it is so significant to balance both the employer’s obligation to accommodate an employee’s rights and the operational realities of the employment relationship. On the one hand the employee has the right to dignity, equality and fair labour practices, particularly when the employee becomes ill or is injured as a result of factors beyond their control. On the other hand, the employer has operational interests; and cannot be expected to hold positions for incapacitated employees, indefinitely.

In reaching its decision, the Labour Court considered among other authorities, the Parexel International (Pty) Ltd v Chakane NO and Other (2019) 40 ILJ 2344 (LAC). In this case the Labour Appeal Court reaffirmed that an employer is not expected to tolerate an employee’s prolonged absence indefinitely, particularly where the employee cannot provide a clear indication of when they may be able to resume their duties. Furthermore, the court indicated that an inconclusive medical prognosis does not automatically prevent an employer from proceeding with an incapacity investigation. The court further identified three aspects to focus on when determining whether an incapacity dismissal is fair, which is the duration of the absence, the medical evidence and the availability of alternatives to dismissal.

The case of Parexel International (Pty) Ltd v Chakane NO and Other, can further be supported by the case of Kievits Kroon Country Estate (Pty) Ltd v Mmoledi and Others (2014) 35 ILJ 406 (SCA), where the court also recognised that an employer is not required to tolerate an employee’s prolonged absence indefinitely; and an employer has the right to terminate the employment relationship on grounds of incapacity, if deemed necessary.

The principles in this case law must be applied to together with provisions of the LRA, such as section 188, which states that dismissal must for a fair reason and in accordance with a fair procedure. The LRA also has new addition – the Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, which repealed Schedule 8 Code of Good Practice on dismissal. This Code also needs to be considered during the dismissal process. The Code, ensures that the employer makes the relevant considerations when investigating the extent of the employee’s incapacity, such as the nature and requirements of the employee’s position; the period of the employee’s absence; the seriousness and nature of the illness or injury; the extent to which the employee is capable of performing; possibility of securing a temporary replacement; and/or whether alternative arrangement could be reasonably implemented to accommodate the employee. The Code therefore ensures that temporary incapacity does not automatically justify dismissal; and further affords the incapacitated employee an opportunity to state their case during investigations.

The application of legal principles in the Kongo case

Comparing Kongo v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and Other case, to the case law mentioned above and the provisions of the Labour Relations Act. SARU, during its investigations did take into consideration the duration of Ms. Kongo’s absence, in that Ms. Kongo had been absent for a total of 161 days; and according to both SARU’s Employment Relations Policy and Ms. Kongo’s Employment Contract, it states that dismissal may be contemplated where an employee’s illness precluded performance for a period greater than 90 days in a 120-day cycle. Secondly, the SARU, consider the medical evidence which they received from the two medical practitioners which Ms. Kongo had been seeing; and found that she was incapacitated to perform the inherent requirements of her position as a Human Resource Business Partner in operations. The seriousness and nature of the illness was also taken into consideration, in that the SARU realised her mental impairments when it came to planning, problem-solving and judgement abilities, which rendered her incapable of performing. Lastly, the SARU considered, the availability of alternatives to Ms. Kongo’s dismissal, in that they looked at the possibility of transferring Ms. Kongo to a position outside the Human Resources Department; however, there were no suitable vacancies in the other departments and Ms. Kongo’s skills and qualifications were not transferable outside Humann Resources. All these considerations are indicative that investigations of the SARU were both substantively and procedurally fair.

Conclusion

The South African labour law framework is premised on the protection of employees and the promotion of fair labour practices. These protection mechanisms are in place due to the inherent balance in the employment relationship; and seeks to ensure that employees are treated with dignity, fairness, and respect, particularly when faced with circumstances beyond their control, such as illness or injury. However, this is not to say the protection afforded to employees is an absolute shield against accountability, nor can it prejudice employer’s operational interests. The employment relationship requires a balance between the rights and interests of both parties, supported by appropriate checks and balances that ensure fairness, accountability, and reasonableness. The Kongo v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and Others case, illustrates this delicate balance. The case demonstrates that the classification of an illness as “temporary’ does not preclude that the dismissal will be fair; but rather the fairness of decision depends on the procedure followed by SARU, when investigating the matter. This therefore allows for a work environment where the employee protection and employer’s accountability coexist.

Written by Ms Palesa Majake, Candidate Legal Practitioner, Pretoria and reviewed by Ms M Maganbhai-Mooloo, Attorney, Pretoria.

Footnotes

  1. Kongo v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration and Others (C93/2024) [2026] ZALCCT 185 (31 October 2026).
  2. Parexel International (Pty) Ltd v Chakane NO and Others (JA39/2018) [2019] ZALAC 50; (2019) 40 ILJ 2344 (LAC); [2019] 11 BLLR 1245 (LAC) (31 October 2026).
  3. Kievits Kroon Country Estate (Pty) Ltd v Mmoledi and Others (875/12) [2013] ZASCA 189; 2014 (1) SA 585 (SCA); [2014] 3 BLLR 207 (SCA); (2014) 35 ILJ 209 (SCA) (31 October 2026).
  4. Section 188 of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995.
  5. Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, General Notice 3470 of 2025, Government Gazette 53294, 4 September 2025.